16 Comments
User's avatar
Rob Tregaskes's avatar

Thorough and robust dissection and analysis, well done! It’s almost like you studied law or something before studying and executing the art of war! 👌

Expand full comment
Kathy K.'s avatar

Wow, this is so helpful. Thank you for taking the time and effort to provide such a thorough analysis.

Expand full comment
Natalie Shalom🙋's avatar

Is anyone in mainstream media questioning his testimony?? did anyone in the room push back on his testimony? Or is this another case of the lie travelling around the world before the truth has even got its boots on? 🤦🏻‍♀️

Expand full comment
Joe's avatar

No one is interested in challenging these assertions - they want to believe the worst in Israel’s actions and will eat up this kind of testimony like it was mana from heaven.

Expand full comment
Natalie Shalom🙋's avatar

And so once again , Jews are vilified with no actual factual evidence ..l

Expand full comment
Kafr Dhimmi's avatar

No juice no noose

Expand full comment
Veronica Coak's avatar

Superb analysis of quite frankly an utterly bizarre testimony. Already posted my opinion of him on X.

His believers will never change, only Israel is torn apart, literally on October 7th and thereafter for fighting back🤷‍♀️

Expand full comment
snek's avatar

Thank you! This is so helpful to use in future rebuttals (although usually people don't want to hear them because the current narrative is so deeply entrenched in their psyche).

Expand full comment
Rebekah Lee's avatar

Thank you for the careful parsing of this fellow's remarks. I appreciate your continued efforts to dig out and publish facts, even though it sometimes seems like shouting into the wind. After re-posting and sharing, we are able to say we stood with you for the truth.

Expand full comment
Natalie Shelley's avatar

The lying never ends and there is always an audience hungry for Israeli "crimes"😔

Expand full comment
Ian Mark Sirota's avatar

Fantastic analysis.

Sadly, however, his words will be taken as the gospel truth, because when it comes to Israel, the world will believe anything. Because, you know, Jews……..

Expand full comment
Jeppe Trautner's avatar

The injuries in children (several entry wounds with some distance and cube-like shrapnel e.g. iron nails cut into pieces) described by Dr Mamode could well be from IEDs tripped by civilians as Hamas has boobytrapped a large proportion of houses in Gaza.

Expand full comment
Jeff's avatar

How are these people allowed to get away with lying all the time? And no consequences.

Expand full comment
Jacqueline's avatar

Confirmation bias for sure.

Expand full comment
Brent Davis's avatar

Andrew, seriously, you are such a clear-eyed friend and advocate... it's hard to express how much that means. I understand that sometimes when you're on Israeli streets, people seek out selfies with you. I'm not surprised. I'd seek out one myself given the chance. With all the crap being thrown about these days, it's so refreshing to read what you write--unvarnished facts, for once, at last. Please keep doing what you're doing--giving us who believe in the value and prevalence of truth cause to keep on hoping, and cause not to despair. We all love you.

Expand full comment
Sheri Oz's avatar

I appreciate how you parse the professor's testimony.

I wonder if you could similarly parse some controversial IDF statements to show why we should (or should not) accept those as true. It would provide some balance in the analysis of what is being said and written about this war.

Expand full comment