Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ian Mark Sirota's avatar

These are all solid pieces of advice. However, just as the Palestinians (as the expression goes) "never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity" when it comes to getting their own state, Israel too often misses opportunities, particularly when it comes to doing anything that might generate positive PR.

Expand full comment
Zain de Ville's avatar

Andrew, this is an impressive thorough and strategically coherent piece. The breadth of vision across military, diplomatic, informational, and cultural domains and the clarity with which it is sequenced. It’s pure pragmatic statecraft that does not indulgesin moral grandstanding nor retreats into cynicism.

What I find most compelling is that this is not an “ethical” strategy in the conventional sense—and that is precisely its strength. It is, in my view, a pre-ethical architecture: a sanitation of the symbolic and institutional terrain that has long been saturated with bad faith, glorified violence, and moral manipulation. Only once that terrain is cleared—through containment, deterrence, and narrative discipline—can genuine ethical relations begin to emerge. In that sense, this strategy doesn’t bypass ethics; it prepares the ground for them to become possible, perhaps for the first time in this domain.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts